Warning: Brain Meltdown in Progress

So, I'm driving myself crazy with my scifibigbang  story.  Should I go with option 1 or option 2? Despite thinking about it non-stop a lot, I'm no further in making a decision.  I need to get my poor little brain off the two stories, so prompt me, people. 

The fandoms: Star Trek: TNG, Halo, Stargate: Atlantis, Fringe, Legend of Zelda, Eleventh Hour, CSI: NY

The "rules": No slash, no smut...and don't expect kissy romance from me, LOL

*goes back to hitting head on desk*